.avif)
Government payment vendor evaluations often look thorough on paper. An RFP goes out. Responses come back. Demos are scheduled. References are called. A scorecard gets built.
And still, agencies find themselves twelve months into a contract wondering how they missed it — the support gap, the chargeback that came back to the county, the fee structure that wasn’t fully explained, the implementation timeline that bore no resemblance to what was promised.
The issue isn’t that agencies don’t do due diligence. It’s that most evaluation frameworks were built to compare features — not to test the things that actually determine whether a payment vendor will serve you well after the contract is signed.
Here are five questions that separate vendors who deliver from vendors who disappoint.
1. Who absorbs chargebacks — you or us?
This question doesn’t appear on most government payment RFPs. It should be the first one.
When a citizen disputes a payment — a bond, a tax payment, a utility bill — that chargeback has to land somewhere. Some payment vendors pass that liability back to the agency. The dispute becomes a budget problem, a reconciliation headache, and a staff time drain.
The right answer is unambiguous: the vendor absorbs all chargeback risk, entirely, with no exposure to the agency. AllPaid’s model has worked this way for 27 years. Zero chargeback losses to the agency, on every transaction type, across 3,500+ clients.
Ask this question directly. Get the answer in writing.
2. What does this cost the agency?
Government payment contracts have a way of arriving with a clear sticker price and leaving with surprises. Monthly platform fees. Per-transaction charges to the agency. Rate adjustments at renewal. Add-on costs for features that seemed standard in the demo.
The right answer for a government agency is $0 — processing fees are passed to the payer, not the county, with no fees billed to the agency at any point. This is AllPaid’s standard model, not a promotional tier.
Ask for a complete list of every fee the agency could ever be charged. Ask what happens to pricing at renewal. Ask whether there are any conditions under which the agency would pay a processing fee.
3. Is payer support available 24/7 with live people?
Government operations don’t pause after 5 PM. Bond releases happen overnight. Tax payments process on deadlines. Utility bills come due on weekends. When a resident can’t complete a payment and reaches out for help, what happens?
The wrong answer involves a ticket system, an email queue, or a chatbot. The right answer is a live person, available 24/7/365, trained to help with government payment transactions specifically.
Ask your vendor for their support model. Ask whether support is in-house or outsourced. Ask for a reference that has experienced an after-hours support interaction and can speak to what it was actually like.
4. What does implementation actually look like?
Every payment vendor’s sales presentation includes an implementation timeline. Almost none of them accurately reflect the actual resource burden on your team.
Ask for a detailed implementation project plan — not a summary. Understand which integration tasks require your IT team’s time. Understand what staff training looks like and who delivers it. Understand what happens when something goes wrong during go-live.
AllPaid’s standard implementation is 30–60 days. AllPaid handles configuration, integration with your existing systems, and staff training. Most agencies describe the experience as faster and simpler than they expected. Ask for a reference from an agency that completed an implementation in the last 18 months with a similar technical environment, and ask them directly how it went.
5. What is your government client retention rate, and how long is your average tenure?
This is the most important question on the list. And the one most agencies never ask.
Retention rate is the single best indicator of whether a vendor delivers on its promises after the contract is signed. A high retention rate means the agencies who have gone through implementation, experienced the platform under real operational conditions, and evaluated it at renewal time have chosen to stay. That collective judgment is more reliable than any demo or reference call.
AllPaid: 98% government client retention, sustained across 27 years and 3,500+ agencies.
Ask for the government-specific retention rate. Ask for average client tenure. Ask how many clients have been with them for more than ten years. If the vendor can’t answer those questions clearly and specifically — or pivots to talking about their feature roadmap — that tells you something important.
“Features are easy to build. Trust takes 27 years.”
Vendors who can answer these five questions clearly, specifically, and with references have earned the right to be evaluated seriously. Vendors who can’t deserve the scrutiny.
See how 3,500+ agencies answered these questions for themselves in the AllPaid Trust Report.
.png)
.png)
